As noted in my 12/30/17 post, in his fourth letter to Lucilius, Seneca quotes Epicurus' maxim that "Poverty is great wealth when it adjusts to nature's law". In Letter 5, Seneca goes on to flesh out his view of the Stoic concept of nature for Lucilius in good-humored (or perhaps sarcastic) fashion:
"Our aim is to live in accordance with nature, is it not? This is contrary to nature: tormenting one's body, swearing off simple matters of grooming, affecting a squalid appearance, partaking of foods that are not merely inexpensive but rancid and coarse. A hankering after delicacies is a sign of self-indulgence; by the same token, avoidance of those comforts that are quite ordinary and easy to obtain is an indication of insanity. Philosophy demands self-restraint, not self-abnegation -- and even self-restraint can comb its hair. The limit I suggest is this: our habits should mingle the ideal with the ordinary in due proportion, our way of life should be one that everyone can admire without finding it unrecognizable."
Here Seneca seems to be making an argument in favor of moderation ("... our habits should mingle the ideal with the ordinary in due proportion ...") which is the founding principle of this blog. The passage also brings to mind Aristotle's doctrine of the mean, discussed in my post of 10/19/17. As readers may recall, in Book II of the Nicomachean Ethics, Aristotle defined virtues as the mean between excess and deficiency. Regarding temperance, for example, he said it was destroyed by excess (licentiousness) and deficiency (insensibility) but preserved by the mean.
In closing, it is worth noting that Seneca authored a separate treatise called "Natural Questions" -- also included in the University of Chicago's recent series of translations of his complete works into English -- which I hope to read some day.
_______________
Aristotle, Nicomachean Ethics (Penguin Classics, London, 2004; original translation by Thomson, revised by Tredennick, introduction by Barnes), Book II, page 34, pages 40-49; see also Appendix 1.
Seneca, Letters on Ethics to Lucilius, Translated with an Introduction and Commentary by Margaret Graver and A.A. Long (University of Chicago Press, Chicago and London, 2015), Letter 5, 4-5, page 32.
Search This Blog
Showing posts with label Mean. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Mean. Show all posts
Friday, January 19, 2018
Thursday, October 19, 2017
What Did Aristotle Mean By Boasting?
As promised in my first post, I will be focusing on Aristotle's discussion of the doctrine of the mean in this post. However, I want to let all of my readers -- both of them -- know that in my next post, I intend to consider an ancient Eastern perspective on moderation.
My first exposure to the classical Greek thinker Aristotle was in college: I recall reading parts of the Poetics in English class, and some of the Politics in a Philosophy course. In law school, I had a course in which we read the Rhetoric. But the subject of this post is the Nicomachean Ethics, which I only got around to reading in the past decade. Aristotle discusses his concept of the mean in Book II of the Ethics. He makes clear that he is not focusing on the mean in relation to things. In mathematics, by way of illustration, Aristotle observes that between 10 and 2 the mean is 6. Instead, he is concerned with the mean in relation to humans, especially regarding moral virtue. For Aristotle, this virtue is the mean between two kinds of vice: excess and deficiency. He says, for instance, that between the deficiency of cowardice and the excess of rashness lies the mean of courage. However, Aristotle acknowledges that not every action admits of a mean: for example, adultery and murder and theft are evil in themselves.
One reason that that a philosopher like Aristotle is still being read and published more than 2,000 years after his death is that his ideas still have application to the modern world. So I will end this post with a quote from Book IV of the Ethics, which could have been written about President Trump's character yesterday:
References:
The passage quoted above can be found on pages 105-107 of the Penguin Classics version of Aristotle's Nicomachean Ethics (Penguin Books, London, 2004; original translation by Thomson, revised by Tredennick, introduction by Barnes); Aristotle's main discussion of the doctrine of the mean can be found on pages 40-49.
My first exposure to the classical Greek thinker Aristotle was in college: I recall reading parts of the Poetics in English class, and some of the Politics in a Philosophy course. In law school, I had a course in which we read the Rhetoric. But the subject of this post is the Nicomachean Ethics, which I only got around to reading in the past decade. Aristotle discusses his concept of the mean in Book II of the Ethics. He makes clear that he is not focusing on the mean in relation to things. In mathematics, by way of illustration, Aristotle observes that between 10 and 2 the mean is 6. Instead, he is concerned with the mean in relation to humans, especially regarding moral virtue. For Aristotle, this virtue is the mean between two kinds of vice: excess and deficiency. He says, for instance, that between the deficiency of cowardice and the excess of rashness lies the mean of courage. However, Aristotle acknowledges that not every action admits of a mean: for example, adultery and murder and theft are evil in themselves.
One reason that that a philosopher like Aristotle is still being read and published more than 2,000 years after his death is that his ideas still have application to the modern world. So I will end this post with a quote from Book IV of the Ethics, which could have been written about President Trump's character yesterday:
"Let us now deal similarly with those who exhibit truth and falsehood in their speech and actions, i.e. in their pretensions. Well, the boaster is regarded as one who pretends to have distinguished qualities which he possesses either not at all or to a lesser degree than he pretends. ... Falsehood is in itself bad and reprehensible, while the truth is a fine and praiseworthy thing; accordingly the sincere man, who holds the mean position, is praiseworthy. ... The boaster is considered to be the opposite of the sincere man. ..."
_______________References:
The passage quoted above can be found on pages 105-107 of the Penguin Classics version of Aristotle's Nicomachean Ethics (Penguin Books, London, 2004; original translation by Thomson, revised by Tredennick, introduction by Barnes); Aristotle's main discussion of the doctrine of the mean can be found on pages 40-49.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
Procrastination
I want to begin by apologizing for the time that has elapsed since my last post; sadly, I have been guilty of procrastination. Like mos...
-
I apologize to my regular readers for the unusual length of time between posts, but my elderly mother fell and broke her hip last month...
-
My mother-in-law Faye Striftis Kalesperis passed away earlier this month. Faye spent most of the first three decades of her life in and...
-
One of the concepts that comes up most frequently in Seneca's letters to his friend Lucilius is fortune. If one were to make a list...