Search This Blog

Showing posts with label Plato. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Plato. Show all posts

Sunday, February 25, 2018

7: The Un-Wisdom Of Crowds

     I want to begin by apologizing to my readers for the unusual length of time between posts. My job search -- discussed in my 12/11/17 post ("Philosophers And Bathroom Attendants") -- is finally over, at least for the time being. I recently started a position as a contract lawyer, reviewing documents in a large antitrust case. In order to prepare myself for this project, which may last six months, I had to brush up on the basics of the rules of evidence (particularly relevancy and privileges), which I had not focused on since law school.
     But now back to Seneca. In the seventh letter to his friend Lucilius, Seneca relates a recent experience that deeply disturbed him. Apparently, he decided to the see the noontime show at an arena -- the Colosseum would not open until 80 AD/CE, 15 years after Seneca's death -- hoping for amusement. Instead, he found carnage. It seems that criminals were given lethal weapons and then ordered to fight to the death for the crowd's pleasure. Unlike gladiators, who typically fought with helmets and shields, the prisoners had no protective gear. As more blood flowed, the spectators became more excited and more blood-thirsty. Seneca told Lucilius:
          "Do you ask what you should avoid more than anything else? A crowd. It is not yet safe for you to trust yourself to one. ... [C]ontact with the many is harmful to us. Every single person urges some fault upon us, or imparts one to us, or contaminates us without our even realizing it. Without doubt, the larger the group we associate with, the greater the danger. Nothing, though, is as destructive to good character as occupying a seat in some public spectacle, for then the pleasure of the sight lets the faults slip in more easily. What do you suppose I mean? Do I come home greedier, more power-hungry, more self-indulgent? Worse than that! I become more cruel and inhumane, just because I have been among humans." 
     Seneca was not the first or the only classical Western thinker who had a low regard for the masses. The ancient Greek philosopher Plato -- to cite but one example -- never forgave the Athenians for voting to convict and then sentence to death his teacher Socrates in 399 BC/BCE. Seneca closes the letter with the following advice for Lucilius: "Direct your goods inward."
_______________

     Seneca, Letters on Ethics to Lucilius, Translated with an Introduction and Commentary by Margaret Graver and A.A. Long (University of Chicago Press, Chicago and London, 2015), Letter 7, 1-3, pages 34-35; see also 12, page 37. 
   

Sunday, October 15, 2017

Memo From Mediocristan

     During the last four years at my most recent employer, I worked on risk management issues. His discussion of risk is what initially brought me to Nassim Nicholas Taleb's The Black Swan: The Impact of the Highly Improbable. Although Taleb's focus is on financial risk -- among other topics -- and mine was on insurance, I would recommend this book to anyone in either field.
     Perhaps the main argument of The Black Swan is that the modern world has become a place that Taleb calls "Extremistan" but that the tools most thinkers use to understand it -- for example, the bell curve -- come from the ancestral place he calls "Mediocristan."
     However, as a former history major, I was pleasantly surprised by Taleb's extensive discussion of ancient Western thinkers. At the risk of oversimplifying his complex arguments, the Greek philosopher Plato is the ancient villain of The Black Swan, due to his tendency to place everything into pure, well-defined, and rigid conceptual categories. (Note that there is no shortage of modern villains in the book, including mainstream economists). Taleb's ancient hero is the pyrrhonian skeptic Sextus Empiricus, who arguably has the best philosophical name ever, and who believed that the only route to tranquility was via the suspension of judgment.
     But I was also surprised by the fact that the Greek philosopher Aristotle -- although he is referenced in a few other places in the book -- is not mentioned by Taleb during his discussion of "Golden Mediocrity" (in chapter 15 of The Black Swan).  My understanding is that Aristotle was the first Western thinker to systematically discuss moderation, and it is to that discussion -- from his Ethics -- that I will turn in my next post.
__________

References:
     Nassim Nicholas Taleb, The Black Swan: The Impact of the Highly Improbable (New York, Random House Trade Paperbacks, Second Edition, 2010).
   

Procrastination

     I want to begin by apologizing for the time that has elapsed since my last post; sadly, I have been guilty of procrastination. Like mos...